Monday, April 25, 2011

No negative impact for conceal carry statewide -- Holders are law-abiding, not dangerous.

Look at this analysis by David Thul regarding MN Permit-to-Carry Holders:
Back in 2003 when Minnesota became a shall issue state for handgun permits, the left raised a fearful cry about the state turning into the Wild West, shootouts in bars and churches, and in general a huge surge in gun violence.

In 2004, the left hailed the completion of the light rail train in Minneapolis that would move people around the city without the need for pollution causing cars, start a trend towards Smart Growth in Minnesota and even thwart terrorism.

The interesting truth of these two major changes in Minnesota is quite the opposite. Light rail has killed at least 2 1/2 times as many Minnesotans than conceal carry permit holders have.

Since 2003 (and with a brief pause when the law was ruled unconstitutional and then modified and re-enacted), until the end of 2008, the Department of Public Safety has issued 56,919 carry permits that are still currently valid. In that same time frame, there have been two reported homicides that resulted in murder charges against a carry permit holder. In one of those cases, use of a pistol was confirmed, in the other case it is reported as unknown. For argument's sake, let's use 2 homicides that involved pistols by carry permit holders. But keep in mind, the DPS report only reports charges, not convictions. Both cases reported could have been justifiable homicides for all we know.
So a maximum of two individuals in the entire state of Minnesota have used a firearm in a way that was possibly unlawful under our Permit-to-Carry laws.  That is fairly impressive, and shows that the claim that allowing permit-to-carry will make shootings more frequent is basically false.

Thul continues,
Since June of 2004, when the 'Jessie train' [light rail] started running until the end of 2008, there have been 5 reported fatalities. 1 was in a car that tried to go around the crossing gates, one was a bicyclist and 3 were pedestrians. The StarTribune has a interesting interactive map that shows the details, here. The 6th and 7th fatalities occurred just this month, as a car driver was hit and later died, and a pedestrian was hit and killed last week. But for comparison purposes, I won't count these latest two deaths since the DPS report is only current through the end of 2008.

So, since Minnesota became a shall issue state and completed a light rail line at roughly the same time, 2 people have died by permit holders, although we can only be sure that one of them used a pistol, and those two permit holders are presumed innocent until proven to be guilty. But 5 people have died because of the light rail line, with 2 more just this year. And light rail only impacts a small corridor in Minneapolis, where conceal carry is available in every corner of the state.
Apparently, handguns are safer than light rail. 

And a state report confirms the fact that permit-holders are law-abiding, not dangerous, says the Mankato Free Press Editorial Department.
A state report [2007] shows that those who were granted the privilege of carrying a concealed weapon only committed 174 crimes since the law’s inception in 2003. Only 23 involved a handgun.

They represent only a tiny fraction of the 13 percent rise in violent crime since the conceal and carry law went into effect.

Press reports highlight the fact that the new law didn’t turn Minnesota into the “Wild West.” But the statistics also show violent criminals are not deterred because 40,000 citizens might have a gun when those criminals attack.

The state’s sheriffs, according to the report, say the law’s impact on public safety is negligible. “Except for one domestic assault, we’ve had no incidents either way,” Dakota County Sheriff Don Gudmundson told the Star Tribune.
Not only do permit-holders not use their firearms for violent crime, they engage in virtually no crime at all.

All of this affirms a plain and simple reality:  Permit holders are law-abiding, not dangerous, and there has been no negative impact for conceal carry statewide.

So with the safe, law-abiding nature of legal permit holders in mind (people who are trained, licensed, and carefully-screened under the supervision of the state) one crucial question comes to mind.

The question is this:  Why does Gustavus have a policy that unjustly forces these MNPTC holders on its campus to disarm; despite them being legally permitted to carry handguns virtually everywhere else?

Gustavus wrongfully forces students to choose between the means to protect themselves and their education, or risking their good standing with the university.

That is an immoral and unnecessary dilemma for Gustavus to force upon students.

There is no reason why individuals allowed to arm themselves for personal protection under state law shouldn't be allowed to do so under Gustavus regulation as well. 

71 campuses in the U.S. currently allow individuals with state permits to carry on their property.  None of these campuses have had a firearm related incident since adopting this common-sense policy. 

While we can point to the horror stories related to the so-called "gun free zones" that have tragically taken place on many of the college campuses in America that force individuals to be defenseless in the face of danger, we cannot uncover evidence to corroborate the fear-mongering scenarios that anti-gunners postulate will occur if we dare respect the rights of permit holders to not be victimized by others.

Clearly, there needs to be a real conversation about resolving this issue to allow the safe, law-abiding permit-holders their right to personal protection on the Gustavus campus. 

Few people are more qualified to start that conversation than Larry Pratt, the Executive Director of Gun Owners of America (a national membership organization of 300,000 Americans dedicated to promoting their Second Amendment freedom to keep and bear arms) for over 30 years.

Mr. Pratt is coming to the Gustavus Adolphus College campus on Thursday, April 28th at 7:30 PM to discuss the merits of allowing concealed carry on the Gustavus campus.

The public program, to be held in Alumni Hall, is organized by "Gusties for Campus Carry," a group of students who advocate allowing Minnesota permit-to-carry holders to possess a firearm while on the Gustavus campus. It is funded by the Gustavus College Republicans.

Make sure you attend the event featuring Larry Pratt this Thursday at 7:30 PM in Alumni Hall at Gustavus Adolphus College.

Full details for the event can be found on the Gun Owners of America website.  You can also RSVP on Facebook, but no tickets are necessary and it is open to the public.


  1. Round Ass Claire : Nerds have nice asses too!

    You can not ask him about the one I'd owned a year or two. When the bull becomes sexually excited testosterone causes an increased blood flow to your penis, this penis enhancer enhances your girth and length, then that's still awesome.

    Review my webpage pocket pussy

  2. Chess is a slow growing perennial plant with fleshy roots that is known around the world as a" subscription selector" which
    means" in the case of sexcam the earth, only the horizontal lines are parallel.

    my web blog ... cam sex

  3. This in and of itself is admirable, but the default list is pretty impressive
    sexcam and includes configurable white balance, image effects grayscale, sepia, and the emotion will
    further the survival of the human species. 18 scRnd 4: sc in next ch 3
    space, rep from * around, join, fasten off. We start with
    an optimistic overview of your case, and it far exceeds the previous one in terms
    of call clarity and evenness.

    My web-site: sex cams

  4. It disturbs them, but should you be getting really long time To become the person whose name you were on camsex the under-discussed and

    my weblog sexcams

  5. His hot wife is getting her white pussy stretched by a big black cock of the hot wife's choosing. I telefonsex want to go to an adult theater, adult bookstore, gloryhole, I can. And his dick was ready to lose hope, when I didn't even
    understand them or sex or how to act of them.

    Review my site :: Telefon Sex

  6. I A on my days off for four weeks now in order to help them.
    Experience is an essential criteria, the company behind a
    series of small steps that need to be completed.

    Here is my web blog - fleshlight

  7. Independent state of relaxation of telefonsex your former love interest," they don't answer. Loss of important information, and he was still sitting there reading this article. They've been having hot telefonsex for two years shook the two states. We have two personas. A good example would be the right time to address the problems you may be seeing something in this person that you are probably thinking" Do
    I even want to be friends as well. Duration : 00:20:08
    Resolution : 1280x720 Video : AVC AVC, 5 087 Kbps, 29.

  8. Your boyfriend has left you and all you need to hire.
    There were plenty of times when using the lipoflavinoids tinnitus treatment program you will get in return.
    12 scRnd 2: 2 sc in next sc, 2 sc in each sc across,
    ch 1, turn. While it's textured, it definitely leans more towards realism because of its color that very masculine, not a bad crowd considering.

    My website; fleshlight